Tokenized Assets Are Live. Should Tokenized Money Should Come Next?

What happens next, now that tokenized assets are moving in a live environment? The Digital Dollar Project and DTCC gathered senior practitioners to discuss just that.

For decades, securities sat in a secure vault, with ownership recorded by intermediaries in siloed, accounts-based systems. But now, tokenized securities can move between wallets around the clock, even on a Saturday, long before traditional banking hours resume. Tokenization also has the potential to enable real-time collateral management, reducing friction, improving transparency, and increasing efficiency in financial markets This was the future described at a closed-door event on November 10, convened by the Digital Dollar Project and hosted by The Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC) under the Chatham House Rule. It brought together senior figures from market infrastructure, government, stablecoin issuers, law firms, consultancies and banks to discuss the future of digital assets, privacy and settlement.

In October, The Depository Trust Company (DTC), a subsidiary of DTCC, launched the DTCC Tokenization Service, allowing eligible DTC participants, to convert eligible DTC-custodied securities between traditional book-entry and tokenized form and transfer them between DTC-registered wallets on supported blockchain networks. The voluntary service creates a a 1:1 tokenized representation of the underlying security entitlement while preserving the security’s CUSIP, legal rights, economic interests and investor protections. Other market participants, including transfer agents and trading venues, are also exploring alternative tokenization models, with the SEC’s Innovation Exemption providing a framework for certain forms of tokenized stock trading The question now is no longer whether traditional securities markets can be tokenized. They can and have been. The question is whether the cash opposite the securities can keep pace, and which form of cash it should be, so that the securities and money can move together reliably and at scale.

Event participants left with a largely shared conviction that the cash leg will take more than one form and that privacy and accountability have to be contemplated and built in from the start, rather than being added in later.

Digital Money Types Will Coexist

There was broad agreement that no single form of money will dominate the settlement of tokenized transactions. Participants suggested that stablecoins, tokenized deposits, and on-chain versions of central bank reserves will all play a part, with different uses across different types of trades, trading venues and environments, and transaction sizes. Tokenized treasuries and money market funds could also play an important role in liquidity and collateral management.

For large wholesale transactions, participants agreed that this is likely to mean legal and final settlement in central bank money. As a risk-free settlement asset, central bank money could unlock institutional adoption of tokenized trading at scale and help reduce the amount of liquidity tied up intraday. Participants were divided on whether the United States should move faster toward a wholesale central bank settlement instrument.

For smaller transactions, financial institutions may consider settling intraday in private digital money, such as stablecoins and tokenized deposits. These instruments carry different credit risks, with payment stablecoins subject to the regulatory framework established by the GENIUS Act.

More important than competition between these types of money is interoperability between them, so that participants can move seamlessly between different forms of money and venues. Some participants suggested this would need an orchestrator to manage the transitions and the potential discrepancies in their valuations. Each instrument’s value will depend not only on whether it can move between digital environments, but also on the likelihood that it redeems at par.

Asked what they need from a settlement asset, institutions boiled it down to three questions. Is settlement final? Does it redeem at par? And can I get it on a Saturday? Some forms of digital money will pass these tests more easily than others, which is one reason participants expected different instruments to coexist.

Others questioned whether trading at 3am on a Saturday is a benefit anyone actually wants. Institutions may not want to trade around the clock, but they do want money and collateral available when and where they need them, which is why collateral was singled out as a critical near-term use case.

Once money can move around the clock, participants expect money resting in an account to earn interest, and only some forms of money will be able to do that.

Privacy and Transparency Matter

Participants disagreed more sharply on how the future of money should be designed. They differed on how markets should be structured, how fast policy should move, and how privacy and identity checks should work once tokenized cash is more broadly adopted by end users.

When DTC took its Tokenization Service live in October under SEC no-action relief, DTC Participants were able to tokenize security entitlements relating to an initial set of 34 eligible securities, representing approximately $30 trillion of the $114 trillion in securities held at DTC. Some 20 firms signed agreements to access the service, and more are expected to follow as the service expands

Separately, on September 17, the SEC issued an Innovation Exemption allowing qualifying venues to offer trading in tokenized stocks, even where the tokens are created by third parties rather than the issuer.

Those favoring a central depository model said keeping tokens tied to existing custody chains preserves a single authoritative record on a security, along with the associated rights and investor protections. Some noted other operating models might widen access or allow for more innovation, even if it splits liquidity across venues.

In either model, it was unclear how much transparency participants wanted. Some public blockchain allows anyone to trace the on-chain movement of tokens and some saw that as a safeguard in its own right. One warned that tokenized assets might come to resemble securitized products at the heart of the 2008 financial collapse, where the layers were visible but the underlying exposures were harder to see.

Privacy questions were also left unresolved. The first was who should carry responsibility for knowing the customer in tokenized transactions. The second was how to verify AI agents acting on behalf of clients, and whether their authority is still valid at the moment they act. The third was what the structure of a future digital U.S. dollar could look like, with a strong desire for a solution that protects it as a reserve currency and upholds the same core values as fiat does today.

Participants made clear that the choice is not between total surveillance and total anonymity. Much of the concern about a future CBDC centers on what governments will be able to see, but some participants pointed out that governments can already trace much of the activity behind their currencies and can buy data about payments from brokers who trade in it. The goal is for information to reach third parties only if the recipient has a legitimate role and a defined purpose, under pre-agreed conditions.

Another concern was how long a hybrid marketplace, bridging traditional markets and emerging digital asset markets, would need to exist while the unresolved issues are worked out.

The Digital Dollar Project welcomes ongoing discussion on these topics and will continue to convene similar discussions with the intention of publishing a white paper on privacy and the digital dollar later this year.

EXPLORE MORE